Why don’t students like school… In 30 mins!

by | Thursday, August 08, 2013

hateschool-calvin

One of the challenges faced by all instructors is ensuring that students actually read the textbook. This summer we came up with a innovative assignment to address this issue. The book in question was  Daniel Willingham’s Why Don’t Students Like School? A cognitive scientist answers questions about how the mind works and what it means for the classroom. 

We called it the 3 x 3 x 3 project since their task was to create a video overview for each of the chapters in the book under the following guidelines:  the video should be no more than 3 minutes long, it would provide 3 key ideas from the chapter and 3 practical implications of these ideas for educators and for teaching (hence 3 x 3 x 3!).

Beyond that we provided no constraints on the technology to be used, style to be followed. SInce we had 5 groups and the book has 9 chapters and a conclusion, each group got to create two of these short videos.

Here are the 10 videos the students created. In essence these 10 videos are a video summary of the book in 30 minutes! Enjoy.

why-students-dont-like-school  

Chapter 1: Why don’t students like school?

Chapter 2: How can I teach students the skills they need when standardized tests require only facts?

Chapter 3: Why do students remember everything that’s on television and forget everything I say?

Chapter 4: Why is it so hard for students to understand abstract ideas?

Chapter 5: Is drilling worth it?

Chapter 6: What is the secret to getting students to think like real scientists, mathematicians, and historians?

Chapter 7: How should I adjust my teaching for different types of learners?

Chapter 8: How can I help slow learners?

Chapter 9: What about my mind?

Chapter 10: Conclusion

A few randomly selected blog posts…

Open source conferencing

Just found out about Dimdim (bad name!) from Manas Chakrabarti's blog, At Any Rate. Dimdim is an opensource, free web conferencing service where you can share your desktop, show slides, collaborate, chat, talk and broadcast via webcam with absolutely no download...

A systems view of technology infusion

A systems view of technology infusion

One of the significant changes in my way of thinking about technology integration has been a shift in focus—away from designing training and programs that target individual teachers to designing systems (both at K12 and higher education levels) that support teachers...

How artists work

An interesting (and growing) collection of "habits, rituals and small (and occasionally big) methods people and teams use to get their work done. And in the specific anecdotes and the way people describe their own relationship to their own work." Kind of cool and...

India Breakfast, a photo report

The India themed breakfast at the College of Education, a kick-off for India Week, was a great success. [Here is a previous blog entry announcing this (and other) events.] I would like to take this opportunity to thank all the people who helped out, and also provide...

No excuses! Veja du (or don’t you)

Excusado by Edward Weston I have written earlier about the idea of veja du (which ended up becoming an assignment in my creativity class). To recap: ... if déjà vu is the process by which something strange becomes, abruptly and surprisingly familiar, véjà du is the...

Bringing sensory richness to bleak scientific texts

A while ago I had written about how we use language to capture intangible ideas - and the risks associated with not paying attention to these intangibles. I had said (though you can read the complete post A different language): For instance wine connoisseurs have...

Henriksen & Mishra, one of popular articles of 2015

Our recent article in TCRecord on how exemplary teachers incorporate creativity in their teaching (Henriksen & Mishra, 2015) was listed as one of the most popular articles of 2015! You can access the article by clicking the link above and, for the record, see...

Designing learning in a transformed world: Keynote

Designing learning in a transformed world: Keynote

I was recently invited to present virtually at The Heart of Innovation Summer Summit, organized by the Heartland Area Education Agency in Iowa. The video of my talk can be seen below. Maybe my first serious keynote talk about generative AI and education. Enjoy...

On finding the right (parking) spot

I had posted earlier about a "virtual speed bump" a visual illusion that make drivers think that they were approaching a speed bump when in actuality it was just a design cleverly painted on the ground. Now here's another one: Directions in a car park... As the...

13 Comments

  1. sherine

    In my opinion, some of the parents and kids are friendly at their home or where ever they are. alike teachers do the same action by getting respect will surely makes the students starts loving their teachers as well as their schools..

    Reply
  2. Marianne

    Are the student videos still available for viewing? I can’t seem to click on them. Thank you!

    Reply
    • Punya Mishra

      I had to move my web host when I moved to Arizona – and lots of links appear to have broken. Thanks for pointing it out. I have fixed it now. ~ punya

      Reply
  3. Marianne

    Are the student videos still available for viewing? I can’t seem to click on them.

    Reply
  4. Victor Delclos

    I have used this wonderful text in a variety of ways in both undergraduate and graduate Ed Psych courses. It is very accessible and a great summary of much of the best research in the field.
    This semester I assigned single chapters to small groups and had them do a half-hour Presentaion linking the chapter to material previously covered in class. One of the groups found this site and included the video from this site as a wrap up.
    You have given me food for thought for future courses via this posting. Thanks.

    Reply
  5. Mike Cusack

    I’m a big fan of this book and was very pleased to find this collection of videos. They’re all very effective at summarizing the concepts, and the conclusion video sums the book up very concisely. Well done, I’ll be sharing it with colleagues.

    Reply
  6. Punya Mishra

    @Jedd, absolutely true. Creating the videos is far more pedagogically significant than watching them. That said, I do think that showcasing student work is always a good thing. AND, maybe someone somewhere may find it useful as an intro to the book. ~ punya

    Reply
    • Adam

      I am one of those people who have found this showcase of student work inspiring and helpful. I had read and loved Willingham’s book last summer but needed a refresher and this was perfect and engaging. Additionally, it was inspiring since I’m an instructional designer and love the idea of assigning students to make similar summary videos in other applications. When I go in to work today I plan to show my supervisor in hopes we can use this sort of assignment in some of our courses.

      I really hoped I could see Chapter 3’s video but it appears it’s set to private! Would it be possible to make this video public?

      Also, would you happen to have any sort of rubric you used for assessing student achievement in this assignment?

      Thanks for doing this and publishing the results!

      Reply
      • Punya Mishra

        Thanks Adam. Since the videos are hosted on student’s own accounts I am not sure why Ch. 3 is private. I am trying to find out and hopefully will have a solution soon.

        I think we had a somewhat holistic rubric since the videos were part of a broader set of summer courses and assignments. Essentially for the videos we looked at process (how the group went about reading, discussing, planning and implementing the videos), content (did they do a good job of representing the big ideas) and product (quality of video, audio etc.). One could, with minimal work, convert this into a rubric. Thanks ~ punya

        Reply
        • Adam Minnie

          Thank you Punya. Those criteria certainly work for me to develop into a rubric as needed. They’re similar to how we have assessed some group media projects we have.

          I greatly appreciate your prompt response and accessibility. I suspect I may have many more questions for you in the future, about the TPACK framework, the Deep-Play Research group, and other interests we may have in common.

          Reply
          • Punya Mishra

            You are welcome. Keep in touch. ~ punya

          • Punya Mishra

            Chapter 3 video is now online ~ punya

  7. Jedd

    The value is in the creation of the video, right? Video can be a (relentless) linear narrative, and work against the processes required for metacognitive thinking and deep understanding. Increasing levels of activity encourage better learning so naturally producing these videos will have been far more effective pedagogically that learners passively watching it. Nice job.

    Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Why students don’t like school – Daniel T. Willingham | monikaniehot - […] Why students don’t like school – Daniel T. Willingham […]
  2. Diigo links 08/09/2013 | DrAlb - […] Why don’t students like school… In 30 mins! | Punya Mishra’s Web […]

Leave a Reply to Marianne Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *