TPACK & the moon OR why I love the web

by | Friday, March 27, 2009

I recently blogged (here and here) about the experiment conducted by students in Italy that allowed them to use publicly available NASA audio recordings from the moon landings to determine the distance between the earth and the moon. I bit more online research led to me to the original paper published on arXiv. arXiv is described as an “e-print service in the fields of physics, mathematics, non-linear science, computer science, quantitative biology and statistics” and is hosted and supported by Cornell University. Reading the paper led me to a writing this posting, since i see this as one of the best examples of the TPACK framework in use that I have come across.

I provide the abstract and a link to the original paper (in pdf format) below and follow that with my thoughts.

Lirlanda, L. (2009). Echoes from the moon. arXIv:0903.3367v1 [physics.ed-ph] 19 Mar 2009.

Abstract: We report on a determination of the Earth-Moon distance performed by students of an Italian high school, based on measurements of the time delay of the “echo” in the radio communications between Nasa mission control in Houston and the Apollo astronauts on the lunar surface. By using an open-source audio-editing software, the distance can be determined with three digits accuracy, allowing to detect the effect due to the eccentricity of the orbit of the Moon.

I strongly recommend reading the complete paper. In my previous posting I had wondered what the role of the teacher (or any other informed adult) was in making this happen. My suspicion was that they were and reading the paper shows me that I was right. This project was done in a classroom with teachers guiding the process, something not emphasized in other places where I had read about this experiment.

Another thing that reading the paper brought home to me was just the complexity of knowledge required by a teacher to pull off something this complex. So what does a teacher need to know? First and foremost, the teacher needs to have a deep knowledge of the content to be covered, physics in this particular case. They need a good knowledge of physics principles and the requisite mathematics.

Also essential is a good knowledge of technology and what can be done with it. Now this is not just knowledge of specialized “physics” software (though they did use a planetary simulation for parts of the research) but of other more generic software as well. For instance, the students used Audacity, an open-source sound editing software, for conducting the analysis of the audio. How many teacher educators would think that knowing Audacity was a requirement for teaching physics? To me this indicates that teachers need to have a special kind of technology knowledge (as opposed to being merely of a specialized kind!). What they need is a flexible kind of knowledge: a kind of knowledge that appreciates ambiguity (and is not frustrated by it) and that is open to seeking and taking advantage of new opportunities and affordances that technology can provide.

The third kind of knowledge that teachers need for such activities is knowledge of pedagogy— i.e. knowledge of how to teach. This has not received much attention but reading the actual paper clearly shows that the instructors brought to bear a great deal of sophisticated knowledge of teaching to the classroom context. This form of knowledge can be inferred from the descriptions provided in the paper, from how the groups were set up to finding the right balance between structure and freedom (for instance once the problem had been introduced the students were given the freedom to devise appropriate methods of measurement of the time-delay).

The most important form of the knowledge though that teachers need goes beyond each of these pieces of knowledge taken in isolation. We can consider the dyads, i.e. knowledge of technology and content, content and pedagogy and pedagogy and technology. An understanding of technology and content, content and pedagogy and technology and pedagogy are important to consider. For reasons of space, however, I will not go into these dyadic overlaps.

There is one more critical overlap that I will should mention and that is the overlap between all three of these knowledge-bases.

What made this project work is that it brought together Content, Technology and Pedagogy in a creative, integrated manner. This form of knowledge is what we call Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK aka, the Total PACKage). This is not just knowledge of physics, or software or teaching but rather the ability to bring the demands (often contradictory) of these disparate domains together in developing a powerful educational experience. This is the art of teaching. This is good design.

The author of the paper describes it best in the discussion section of the paper. As you read this, note the manner in which she brings together physics, the teaching of physics, and the role of technology in one integrated whole. As she says:

The experiment that we have reported represents an example of “open” research-oriented activity, in which no “correct answer” can be anticipated a priori. This aspect should be emphasized whenever possible in the teaching of physics, since it gives students the flavor of what physicists do in their experimental or theoretical work. Another aspect of our experiment – common to most of present-day experimental research in physics – is the analysis of raw data (in our case the audio registrations) by means of sophisticated software, which gives the opportunity to extend the discussion on the “error sources.”

Finally, what is amazing is that the results of an experiment conducted in a school in Italy, based on the analysis of raw data downloaded from a website in the US, conducted with a free open-source software built collaboratively by volunteers from across the world, can be accessed by anybody, within a week of its publication, from an e-print service that offers knowledge freely to one and all! What a wonderful world we live in.

A few randomly selected blog posts…

TPACK tshirt now available

The ambigram design I had first presented here is now available through cafe-press in a variety of formats. Click here to buy t-shirts, buttons and more... Just to be clear, the prices for all the items are exactly what cafe-press charges. Matt and I make no money of...

Help with research (max 10 mins).

This is a request for help. If you are an educator (K12 teacher or administrator, higher ed faculty, corporate trainer etc.) we would like approximately 10 minutes of your time to complete a survey regarding the challenges faced by educators in the 21st century and...

Defense against the dark arts in the Sydney Morning Herald

Defense against the dark arts in the Sydney Morning Herald

I was in Sydney recently to present a keynote at the MITE conference. I spoke there about some issues that have been concerning me for a while—what I like to call the "dark arts" of digital technologies. After the conference I had a wide-ranging interview with Jordan...

TPACK, creativity and friends @ Singapore

I have been in Singapore the past few days at the invitation of Mike Thiruman and his team at Educare. Educare is a co-operative of the Singapore Teachers’ Union and sees itself as serving "teachers and schools so as to enhance the quality of teaching." I had two...

A chat about GPT3 (and other forms of alien intelligence)

A chat about GPT3 (and other forms of alien intelligence)

We recently celebrated the 10-year anniversary of writing a regular column series on Rethinking Technology & Creativity in Education for the journal TechTrends. Over the next few articles in this series, we are going to dive deeper into Artificial Intelligence...

Learning landscapes, special issue on creativity

My friend Teresa Foulger at Arizona State University  informed me about the fact that the journal LEARNing Landscapes has a special issue on creativity.  I had not heard of the journal before and I was pleasantly surprised by the articles in this special issue....

Neuroscience & Creativity: New article

Neuroscience & Creativity: New article

The next article in our series Rethinking Technology & Creativity in the 21st Century for the journal TechTrends was just published.This article features an interview with Dr. Arne Dietrich, professor of neuroscience at the American University...

TPACK & Social Media at Bloomfield Hills

I spent a two days a couple of weeks ago with the faculty and leadership of Bloomfield Hills School District. The first day was a workshop on teaching, technology and creativity with the faculty of Model High School and Bowers Academy. Leigh and I had been invited...

How to complete a half-marathon

I completed the Capital City River Run Half Marathon today. This race has become an annual event for me, this being my 7th outing so far (the first three years being a 10 mile run before it shifted into a half-maraton). [See links here, here and here]. I completed the...

1 Comment

  1. Padmini

    Indeed what a wonderfully connected and openly genrous world

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *