The gullibility of experts

by | Tuesday, September 02, 2008

Does it matter whether a brownie is served on a paper plate or on china? Is the Patagonian Toothfish less tasty than the Chilean Bass? In an earlier posting (perception of taste) I had cited research showing that wine with an expensive price tag was judged to be better than the same wine with a less expensive tag!

An article in today’s NYTimes (Fish or Foul?) adds to the fun, by providing more evidence of just how gullible we are. (The first two examples above, are taken from that article and as you may have guessed the brownie served on china does taste better, and the Chilean Bass is identical to, but sells much better than, the less appetizingly named Patagonian Toothfish.)

More importantly this article argues that, in certain cases, expertise may actually be a greater liability than ignorance. As the article says, “we taste with both our tongues and our minds, and it is easy to lead minds astray.” The trick is,

finding smart people who bring a lot to the table — cultural experience, shared expectations, preconceptions. The more they bring, the more there is to work with, and the easier it is to get the audience to make allowances — to reach the ‘right’ conclusion and unwittingly participate in the deception.

On a side note, this op-ed in the NYT was prompted by a story about two high-school students who found out that many of the high-end fish being sold at New York restaurants and grocery stores were often mislabeled i.e. cheaper and lower quality fish were being offered with higher-end labels (and prices). Read that story, Fish Tale Has DNA Hook: Students Find Bad Labels

Topics related to this post: Biology | Fun | Psychology | Science

A few randomly selected blog posts…

The medium is the massage

Nicholas Carr has an interesting post (titled Rewiring the mind) on the findings of a recent study into the information seeking behaviors of scholars. (The full study in pdf format can be downloaded here.) Carr seems to suggest that these results indicate a...

TPACK & 21st Century Learning @ AACTE

I was recently in San Diego for the annual conference of the American Association of Colleges of Teacher Education. I had served as a chair of the Innovation & Technology Committee for a while, and the committee invited me to participate in two different sessions....

Unpacking TPACK

Suzy Cox is a lecturer in educational technology and educational psychology at Utah Valley State College and also a doctoral candidate at Brigham Young University (working with Dr. Charles Graham). She is currently working on her dissertation which seeks to develop a...

A cuil new search engine

Cuil (pronounced cool!)... check it out. How does it compare to Google? Functionally? Design-wise?

Happy Diwali

Happy Diwali For an interactive card click here ... . Remember to turn your volume way up, and click anywhere in the sky above the Taj Mahal for some environmentally friendly, fireworks.

Creativity & Teaching, new article in TCRecord

How do exemplary teachers incorporate creativity in their teaching? For her dissertation study, Dr. Danah Henriksen  interviewed several National Teacher of the Year award winners (and finalists), to better understand their beliefs, interests, and practices involving...

India Week @ Erickson Hall

The Indian community in the greater Lansing area celebrates India Week every year (more or less) around March. [More details here and here.] As a part of this event I (and other members of the College of Education) have been organizing an Indian themed breakfast and...

The Allegory of the Cave

Plato's Allegory of the Cave (see Wikipedia entry) illustrates "our nature in its education and want of education." It is maybe one of the most famous allegories in literature and philosophy, a precursor to the kinds of mind-games (think brain in a vat) that...

Squaring a circle on Pi day!

Squaring a circle on Pi day!

Pie upon reflection is nothing but 3.14!A new version of a design I had created a year ago.Original idea stolen from the Interwebs Since it is Pi(e) day, I thought it would be fun to share another design I had created a while ago in response to one of the...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *